Nov 08, 2026

OPINION: Letter to Ks. lawmakers on sentencing junveniles

Posted Nov 08, 2026 8:43 PM

SALINA, KAN. - The following is an opinion piece submitted to the Salina Post 11-8-2026

Fair Sentencing Starts with Understanding the Whole Person

By Madeline Schlyer - first year masters of social work student

How often do we make judgements about others without fully knowing the experiences that shaped them? For many of us, it's common to form opinions about someone's actions, despite not understanding the circumstances that may have caused them. But when those  influential judgments hold the potential to alter the rest of a young person's life, understanding a person's whole picture becomes imperative.

Through my social work field practicum, I had an experience that changed the way I think about judging someone's actions. I previously worked with a client whose actions and attitudes were confusing and difficult to understand. I initially created reasoning for her behavior based on the little information I already knew about her. Later on, I learned more about her past and experiences with trauma, which led me to a clearer understanding of why she behaved in certain ways. This served as an important reminder to me that it's incredibly easy to misunderstand people when we don't know their past experiences (even if we think we do).

The learning opportunity I had through this experience has directly connected to how I view fairness in the justice system, specifically when it involves sentencing young offenders. When one decision can alter the rest of a person's life, we possess a responsibility to address more than just their actions. We must consider the circumstances and past experiences that have influenced them.

In 2012, the Supreme Court highlighted the importance of those considerations in Miller v. Alabama, which ruled that mandatory life without parole sentences for juveniles were unconstitutional. This decision emphasized how adolescents should not be automatically required to be tried as adults, as they are still developing.

This ruling, however, didn't completely eliminate juvenile life without parole sentences, and many questions remain about the consistency of giving young offenders meaningful sentence reconsiderations. Factors like childhood trauma, unstable family environments, and developmental level all contribute to an adolescent's behavior. These factors are not excuses by any means, but rather important considerations when deciding if someone deserves a lifetime in prison.

It's also necessary to recognize that people can change. Somebody who committed a serious offense at age 14 might be a completely different person at age 34. However, it can be difficult to achieve any positive change when individuals do not have access to mental health services, education, or other supportive resources.

This is why Kansas lawmakers should construct more clear and consistent sentence review procedures for people who were given extensive sentences as juveniles. Reviews should address childhood trauma, rehabilitation efforts, their behavior during incarceration, and the safety of the public. Individuals should also have realistic opportunities and access to rehabilitation resources.

I understand that this is a difficult topic, especially for victims facing the effects of trauma and harm. Their stories and safety deserve an immense amount of respect and consideration, and sentence review procedures should never correspond to automatic release of the offender. The goal is to assess the offender and decide if incarceration is still appropriate based on any change and growth they've demonstrated, while still holding them accountable for their actions.

My practicum experience has taught me that understanding an individual's personal circumstances doesn't mean we should ignore and excuse their harmful behaviors. It means we must recognize that there is more to a person than what we notice at the surface level. I urge Kansas lawmakers to utilize that same mindset when it comes to juvenile sentencing and developing opportunities for rehabilitation and sentence review. Fairness should involve considering the person as a whole, not just a piece of their story.